Federalism: Class 10 Civics Chapter 2 Hinglish mein
Democratic Politics · Hinglish notes, simulations aur practice · Official NCERT chapter PDF ↗
Published · Updated
Is chapter mein aap kya seekhenge
- Samjhao ki federalism kya hai aur federal system unitary system se kaise alag hai
- Federation ke key features list karo aur ‘coming together’ federations ko ‘holding together’ federations se alag pehchaano
- Subjects ko Union, State aur Concurrent Lists mein sort karo aur residuary powers, special provisions aur Union Territories samjhao
- Batao ki India ka power-sharing amendment process, courts aur revenue ke alag sources se kaise protected hai
- Samjhao ki linguistic States, language policy aur badalte Centre–State relations ne practice mein federalism ko kaise mazboot kiya hai
- Decentralisation samjhao aur 1992 ke amendments ke baad ki rural aur urban local government ke baare mein batao
- India mein local self-government ki achievements aur kamiyon ko tolo
NCERT Social Science Class 10, Chapter 2, pp. 13–28 par based original companion text. Yeh NCERT se juda nahi hai aur NCERT ne ise endorse nahi kiya hai.
Ek aam din ke baare mein socho. Tumhari jeb mein ₹100 ka note Reserve Bank of India ne jaari kiya hai, aur currency aisa subject hai jis par sirf Union law bana sakti hai. Traffic crossing par khada constable tumhari State government ke liye kaam karta hai. Tumhare ghar ke bahar ki street light, ya tumhare gaon ka hand pump, ek municipality ya gram panchayat sambhaalti hai. Teen governments, har ek chuni hui, har ek ka apna kaam, aur sab ek hi tum par shaasan karti hain.
Chapter 1 mein tumne dekha ki democracy power ko government ke levels ke beech bhi baant sakti hai, sirf government ke organs ya social groups ke beech nahi. Power ki is vertical sharing ko federalism (संघवाद) kehte hain. Yeh chapter pehle is idea ko general roop mein samjhata hai. Phir dekhta hai ki India ka Constitution ise kaise set up karta hai aur politics ne ise kaise chalaya hai. Aakhir mein sabse naye, teesre level ki baat hai: gaon aur shehron ki local government.
2.1 Federalism kya hai?
Chapter 1 do aise countries ke saath khatam hua jinhone alag-alag raaste chune. Dono se ek test question poochho: kya national government apne aap kisi region ki powers chheen sakti hai? 1993 se pehle Belgium mein jawab haan tha, kyunki regional governments ke paas powers sirf centre se udhaar mili hui thi. 1993 ke constitutional changes ke baad jawab nahi ho gaya, kyunki ab woh powers Constitution mein likhi hain. Isi ek change ne Belgium ko unitary se federal country bana diya.
Sri Lanka mein jawab practice mein aaj bhi haan hai: national government ke paas lagbhag saari power hai. Isiliye wahan ke Tamil leaders lambe samay se federal system ki maang karte aaye hain.
Government ka aisa system jismein country ki power ek national government aur uske regions (States ya provinces) ki governments ke beech baanti jaati hai, aur har ek apna hissa constitution ke haq se rakhti hai.
ExampleIndia, USA, Germany aur Australia.
Ek typical federation mein poore country ke liye ek government hoti hai aur har State ya province ke liye ek government. Pehli un sawaalon ko sambhaalti hai jin par country ko ek hokar kaam karna hota hai: borders ki raksha, paisa jaari karna, doosre deshon se deal karna. Doosri zyadatar un cheezon ko sambhaalti hai jinse citizens roz milte hain, police station se lekar farm office tak. Is arrangement ko federal levels ki ginti nahi banati, balki unki power ka source banata hai. Har level apna hissa independently rakhta hai, doosre ke ehsaan ki tarah nahi.
2.1.1 Federal ya unitary?
Federation mein kya khaas hai, yeh dekhne ke liye use uske ulte se compare karo, yaani unitary system (एकात्मक व्यवस्था). Wahan power ek hi jagah rehti hai. Ya to country mein government ka ek hi level hota hai, ya uski regional aur local bodies centre ki agents hoti hain, jo national decisions laagu karne ke liye banayi jaati hain. France aur Sri Lanka isi tarah chalte hain.
Ek simple test farak dikhata hai. Maan lo national government tay karti hai ki har police force ki uniform badli jaaye. Unitary country mein woh bas order de deti hai, aur regions maan lete hain. India mein police State subject hai, isliye New Delhi Kerala ya Punjab ko is baare mein kuch karne ka order nahi de sakti; woh sirf unhe manaane ki koshish kar sakti hai. Apne subjects par State government national government ko report nahi karti. Iske bajaay har level voters ko jawab deta hai, jo dono ko chunte hain. Fig. 2.1 dono systems ko dikhata hai.
4/4Jab levels is baat par asahmat hon ki kis power ka haq kiske paas hai, to courts umpire ka kaam karte hain.
Ek national government box teen chhote boxes ke upar hai. Pehle step mein, jis par unitary likha hai, orders likhe arrows national box se neeche teen provinces tak jaate hain. Doosre step mein system federal ban jaata hai: order arrows gayab ho jaate hain, neeche ke boxes States ban jaate hain, aur dono levels ke neeche ek slab dikhta hai jis par constitution fixes powers likha hai. Teesre step mein neeche citizens ki ek row dikhti hai, jisse dashed arrows upar States aur national government tak jaate hain, yeh dikhane ke liye ki citizens dono levels ko chunte hain. Chauthe step mein upar left mein ek court building dikhti hai, jis par umpire likha hai.
Unitary aur federal systems aamne-saamne
Unitary
- Government ka ek level, ya neeche ke levels jo centre ke agents ki tarah kaam karte hain
- National government neeche ke levels ko order de sakti hai aur unki powers badal sakti hai
- Jaise: France, Sri Lanka
Federal
- Do ya zyada levels, har ek ka power ka apna field
- Har level ki powers constitution tay karta hai; koi bhi doosre ke subjects par doosre ko order nahi de sakta
- Jaise: India, USA, Germany
2.1.2 Federalism ke key features
Federations ek doosre se kaafi alag hoti hain, lekin kuch features sab mein hote hain. Inmein se saat sabse zaroori hain.
- Do ya zyada tiers. Government ke kam se kam do levels hote hain, jaise national aur State.
- Log wahi, fields alag. Har tier unhi citizens par shaasan karta hai, lekin har ek ka apna jurisdiction hota hai: laws banane, taxes collect karne aur administration chalane ke apne subjects.
- Likhit guarantee. Constitution batata hai ki har tier kya control karta hai, isliye koi bhi tier sirf doosre ki marzi par exist nahi karta ya power nahi rakhta.
- Ek-tarfa changes nahi. Power-sharing ke basic rules koi ek tier akele dobara nahi likh sakta; dono tiers ka raazi hona zaroori hai.
- Courts umpire ki tarah. Courts constitution ka interpretation karte hain, aur sabse ooncha court tiers ke beech ke disputes settle karta hai ki kis power ka haq kiske paas hai.
- Apna paisa. Har tier ke revenue ke sources saaf-saaf tay hain, isliye use har rupaye ke liye doosre par nirbhar nahi rehna padta.
- Ek saath do goals. System ka maksad country ko ekjut rakhna hai aur saath hi uski regional variety ke liye jagah chhodna hai.
Kisi government ya court ki legal authority ka daayra: ya to woh territory jo uske under aati hai (ek State, ek district), ya woh subjects jinse woh deal karti hai (police, banking).
ExampleEk State police force sirf usi State ke andar kaam kar sakti hai.
Sirf likhe hue rules se federation nahi chalti. Ek housing society socho jismein har family apna flat khud sambhaalti hai aur ek chuni hui committee lift, gate aur water tank chalati hai. Yeh tabhi chalta hai jab sab kaam ke is batwaare ko maanein aur bharosa karein ki doosre bhi ise nibhaayenge. Federations bhi aisi hi hain. Levels ko pehle power share karne ke rules par sahmat hona hota hai, aur phir ek doosre par bharosa karna hota hai ki woh un rules ka samman karenge. Federation tab sabse mazboot hoti hai jab dono baatein hon: rules ka ek agreed set aur saath rehne ki sachchi chaah.
2.1.3 Federation tak pahunchne ke do raaste
Kuch federations mein centre powerful kyun hota hai aur kuch mein kam? Aksar jawab history mein hota hai, yaani us federation ka janm kaise hua. Janm ki do aam kahaaniyan hain (Fig. 2.2).
Pehli kahaani mein alag-alag countries milne ka faisla karte hain. USA banane wali terah purani British colonies, aur Swiss cantons, sab akele khade rehne se darte the. Isliye unhone common defence ke liye apni independence ka kuch hissa chhoda, lekin apne laws aur identity bachaaye rakhi. Australia ki chhe colonies bhi 1901 mein isi tarah judi. Kyunki members ne union banaya tha, unhone dhyaan rakha ki naya centre limited rahe. Aisi coming together federations mein aam taur par har member ke paas same powers hoti hain, aur members federal government ke muqable powerful rehte hain.
Doosri kahaani mein country pehle se ek unit ki tarah exist karta hai. Woh apne regions ke saath power share karna chunta hai, aksar bahut alag-alag regions ko ek state ke andar santusht rakhne ke liye. 1950 se India, 1978 ke constitution ke under Spain aur 1993 se Belgium ne yahi raasta liya. Kyunki centre ne power neeche se lene ke bajaay neeche di, isliye in holding together federations mein aam taur par centre ka palda bhaari rehta hai. Regions ke saath ek jaisa vyavhaar bhi zaroori nahi: kuch ko language, culture ya history bachaane ke liye special powers milti hain.
3/3Ek bada country asamaan units ke saath power share karta hai; kuch ko special powers milti hain, aur Centre zyada mazboot rehta hai.
Left panel ka heading coming together hai aur right panel ka holding together. Pehle step mein left panel mein teen alag circles hain, States A, B aur C, jin par independent States likha hai, aur right panel mein ek bada circle hai jiske andar Centre likha ek chhota circle hai, jis par one large country likha hai. Doosre step mein circles A, B aur C ek dashed frame ke andar paas aa jaate hain, aur label badalkar equal, strong States ho jaata hai, neeche examples USA, Switzerland aur Australia ke saath. Teesre step mein right ka bada circle chaar asamaan hisson mein kat jaata hai, Centre se teen hisson tak arrows bahar jaate hain, sabse chhota hissa shaded hai aur us par special likha hai, aur label badalkar stronger Centre ho jaata hai, examples India, Spain aur Belgium ke saath.
Federation ki do kisme
Coming together
- Independent States milkar ek bada union banate hain
- Member States ke paas aam taur par barabar powers hoti hain
- States federal government ke muqable mazboot hote hain
- USA, Switzerland, Australia
Holding together
- Ek bada country apne hisson mein power baant-ta hai
- Central government aam taur par zyada mazboot hoti hai
- Units ke paas asamaan powers ho sakti hain; kuch ko special status milta hai
- India, Spain, Belgium
Answer dekho
Answer (C) Unitary system
Answer dekho
Answer (B) Regional governments ko aisi constitutional powers mili jo centre wapas nahi le sakta tha
Answer dekho
- (A) ‘Federalism ka matlab hai ki national government gayab ho jaayegi.’
- (C) ‘Jaise hi hum azaadi se vote de sakenge, hamare paas apne aap federalism aa jaayega.’
Answer dekho
Answer Galat
2.2 India ko federal country kya banata hai?
Belgium aur Sri Lanka chhote countries hain, phir bhi dono ko apni communities ke beech power share karne mein mushkil hui. India bahut bada hai aur kahin zyada diverse, jismein kai languages, religions aur regions hain. Yeh power kaise share karta hai?
India ki federation mushkil samay mein bani. Partition ne abhi-abhi khoon-kharabe ke saath zameen baanti thi, aur 500 se zyada chhote-bade princely states ko naye country mein laana tha. Framers ek mazboot, ekjut India chahte the jo apne regional differences ka samman bhi kar sake. Natija ek aisa Constitution hai jo kabhi federation shabd use nahi karta aur India ko ‘Union of States’ kehta hai. Phir bhi yeh saaf taur par federal system banata hai: pehle list kiye gaye saaton features ismein maujood hain.
1950 mein do tiers the: New Delhi mein Union government, jise Central government bhi kehte hain, aur har State mein ek government. Panchayats aur municipalities thi, lekin sirf State laws ke under. 1992 ke amendments ne unhe ek constitutional teesra tier bana diya, jiska baaki do ki tarah apna jurisdiction hai.
2.2.1 Teen lists
Is arrangement ka dil law banane ki power ka teen-tarfa batwara hai, jo Constitution ke Seventh Schedule mein diya gaya hai (Fig. 2.3).
- Union List (संघ सूची) mein woh subjects hain jin par country ko har jagah ek hi policy chahiye: defence, foreign affairs, banking, currency, railways, aur posts and telephones. Inpar sirf Parliament laws bana sakti hai.
- State List (राज्य सूची) mein State aur local mahatva ke subjects hain: police aur public order, agriculture, irrigation, public health aur hospitals, aur State ke andar trade and commerce. Inpar sirf State legislatures laws bana sakti hain.
- Concurrent List (समवर्ती सूची) mein woh subjects hain jo dono se jude hain: education, forests, marriage aur divorce, adoption aur succession, trade unions aur electricity. Inpar Parliament aur State legislatures dono laws bana sakti hain. Niyam yeh hai ki agar same Concurrent subject par Union law aur State law takraate hain, to Union law hi laagu hota hai.
4/4Residuary subjects, jo kisi list mein nahi hain, Parliament ke paas jaate hain.
Do bade overlapping circles, left wale ka heading Parliament aur right wale ka State legislature. Pehle step mein left circle shaded hai aur defence, banking aur currency ke saath Union List dikhata hai. Doosre step mein right circle shaded hai aur police, agriculture aur irrigation ke saath State List dikhata hai. Teesre step mein overlap shaded hai aur education, forests aur marriage ke saath Concurrent List dikhata hai, aur ek note kehta hai ki takraav hone par Union law jeet-ta hai. Chauthe step mein left circle ke neeche residuary likha ek box dikhta hai jisme ek arrow jaata hai, yeh dikhane ke liye ki jo subjects kisi list mein nahi, un par Parliament laws banati hai.
1950 mein likhi koi bhi list sab kuch pehle se nahi soch sakti thi. Jo matters teeno mein se kisi list mein nahi aate, jaise computer software, unhe residuary subjects kehte hain. Constitution ka Article 248 unhe Parliament ko deta hai, jisse Union ka wazan aur badhta hai.
| List | Law kaun banata hai | Kuch subjects |
|---|---|---|
| Union List | Sirf Parliament | defence, foreign affairs, currency, banking, railways, atomic energy, citizenship |
| State List | Sirf State legislature | police, prisons, agriculture, land, fisheries, public health, local government |
| Concurrent List | Dono; takraav hone par Union law hi laagu hota hai | education, forests, marriage, adoption, trade unions, electricity, criminal law |
| Residuary subjects | Parliament | woh subjects jo kisi list mein nahi hain |
Answer dekho
Answer (D) Nahi, kyunki currency Union List mein hai
Answer dekho
Answer (B) Union law
Left mein koi item tap karo, phir right mein uska match.
Answer dekho
- Police : State List
- Banking : Union List
- Forests : Concurrent List
- Computer software : Residuary (Parliament)
Answer dekho
Answer (1) residuary, (2) Parliament
2.2.2 Har unit ke paas same powers nahi hoti
Holding together federations apni saari units ke saath shayad hi ek jaisa vyavhaar karti hain, aur India bhi alag nahi hai. Articles ka ek group, 371 se 371J tak, kai States ke liye unki khaas history aur society ki wajah se special provisions karta hai. Article 371A lo. Yeh kehta hai ki Naga customary law, religious aur social practices, ya zameen ki ownership aur transfer par Parliament ka koi Act Nagaland mein tab tak laagu nahi hota jab tak State ki Assembly raazi na ho. Article 371G Mizoram ko aisi hi protection deta hai. Yeh provisions kya bachaate hain, yeh jagah ke hisaab se badalta hai. North-east mein yeh tribal zameen aur customary law ki raksha karte hain. Andhra Pradesh, Telangana aur Karnataka ke kuch hisson mein yeh local logon ke liye government jobs aur college seats mein uchit hissa pakka karte hain.
Doosre chhor par aisi units hain jinke paas apni bahut kam power hai: Union Territories (केंद्रशासित प्रदेश). Kuch, jaise Lakshadweep aur Andaman and Nicobar Islands ke dweep samooh, State ki tarah chalne ke liye bahut chhote ya bahut door hain. Aaj India mein aath Union Territories hain. Inke paas State jaisi powers nahi hoti; Union government inhe ek Administrator ya Lieutenant Governor ke zariye chalati hai. Delhi, Puducherry aur Jammu and Kashmir mein chuni hui assemblies hain, lekin unki powers State se kam hain.
2.2.3 Balance ki raksha
Maan lo aage koi Parliament police ko Union List mein daalna chahe. Kya woh bas vote karke aisa kar sakti hai? Nahi. Lists mein, ya powers ke batwaare ke tareeke mein, koi bhi change do rukaavatein paar karta hai (Fig. 2.5). Pehli, Parliament ke har House ko use special majority se paas karna hota hai. Iska matlab hai House ki total membership ka majority aur present aur vote karne wale members ka kam se kam do-tihaai. Doosri, kam se kam aadhi State legislatures ko use approve karna hota hai. Tabhi woh assent ke liye President ke paas jaata hai. Doosre shabdon mein, apni powers ki ek chaabi States ke paas hai.
5/5President assent dete hain, aur change laagu ho jaata hai.
Upar se neeche rakhe paanch boxes jo arrows se jude hain: bill to change the lists, Lok Sabha special majority, Rajya Sabha special majority, half the State legislatures, aur President's assent. Pehle step mein sirf pehla box highlighted hai. Har agle step mein agla box jalta hai aur har paar ho chuke stage ke paas ek tick aata hai, jab tak paanchve step mein paanchon boxes highlighted aur ticked na ho jaayein, yeh dikhate hue ki change laagu ho gaya hai.
Courts umpire ka kaam karte hain. Agar Union aur ek State, ya do States, is baat par asahmat hon ki kis power ka haq kiske paas hai, to dispute courts mein jaata hai. Article 131 ke under Supreme Court governments ke beech ke disputes seedhe sun sakta hai, aur High Courts bhi powers ke batwaare ke bahut se cases ka faisla karte hain.
Aakhir mein, har level ko apna paisa chahiye, isliye Constitution Union aur States ko tax lagane ki alag powers deta hai. Jaise, non-farm income par income tax aur customs duties Union ke paas jaati hain, jabki land revenue aur property documents par stamp duty States ki hain. 2017 se Goods and Services Tax (GST) shared hai. Dono levels ise lagate hain, aur rates ek GST Council mein tay hote hain jahan Union aur har State saath baithte hain.
Answer dekho
Answer (C) Nahi, kyunki defence Union subject hai
Answer dekho
Answer Galat
Answer dekho
Answer (D) Woh aage badh sakta hai, kyunki education Concurrent hai aur State tab tak kaam kar sakti hai jab tak woh kisi Union law ko na tode
- President ka assent
- Dono Houses mein special majority
- Parliament mein bill laaya gaya
- Aadhi State legislatures raazi
Answer dekho
- Parliament mein bill laaya gaya
- Dono Houses mein special majority
- Aadhi State legislatures raazi
- President ka assent
2.3 Federalism practice mein kaise chalta hai?
Constitution sirf ek rulebook hai; asli baat yeh hai ki players kaise behave karte hain. Bahut se countries ke federal constitutions practice mein nazarandaaz kiye jaate hain. India ki federation ummeed se behtar chali hai, aur iski main wajah uski democratic politics hai. Dashakon mein parties, leaders aur citizens ne yeh maan liya ki diversity samman ki haqdaar hai aur country ko ekjut rakhne ke liye power share karni padti hai. Teen developments dikhate hain ki yeh kaise hua.
2.3.1 Linguistic States
Aaj tum jo States jaante ho, zyadatar woh units nahi hain jinse India ne shuruaat ki thi. 1947 mein map ek patchwork tha. Usmein British zamane ke provinces the, jaise United Provinces aur Central Provinces, aur saikdon princely states, jaise Hyderabad aur Mysore. Inmein se lagbhag koi bhi apne purane roop mein nahi bacha. State borders ko is tarah dobara kheenchna ki har bade language group ka apna State ho, India mein democracy ka pehla bada test tha.
Kai national leaders pareshaan the. Partition ne abhi dikhaya tha ki gehri loyalties country ko kaise tod sakti hain, aur unhe dar tha ki language par bane States India ko aur tootne ki taraf le ja sakte hain. Isliye Central government ne shuru mein is maang ka virodh kiya. Kai regions mein movements dabaav banaye rahe. December 1952 mein Telugu bolne walon ke State ke liye lambe fast ke baad Potti Sriramulu ki maut ho gayi, aur agle saal Andhra State bana. Uske baad ek States Reorganisation Commission bana, aur 1956 mein zyadatar State borders language ke aadhaar par dobara kheenche gaye (neeche ki timeline).
India ke States kaise dobara kheenche gaye
- 1953
Andhra State
Mukhya roop se ek language, Telugu, ke liye bana pehla State, 1 October 1953 ko.
- 1956
States Reorganisation Act
1 November 1956 se India mein 14 States aur 6 Union Territories the, jinmein se kai language ke aadhaar par dobara kheenche gaye.
- 1960
Bombay State ka batwara
Marathi bolne wala Maharashtra aur Gujarati bolne wala Gujarat 1 May 1960 ko alag States bane.
- 1963
Nagaland
Naga logon ki alag identity ko maante hue 1 December 1963 ko bana.
- 1966
Punjab ka reorganisation
Haryana alag kiya gaya, aur kuch pahadi ilaake Himachal Pradesh mein gaye.
- 1969–73
Naye naam
Madras State Tamil Nadu bana (1969) aur Mysore Karnataka bana (1973).
- 1971–72
Aur poore States
Himachal Pradesh (1971) aur Manipur, Tripura aur Meghalaya (1972).
- 1975
Sikkim
Sikkim India ka ek State bana.
- 1987
Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh, Goa
Teen Union Territories States bane.
- 2000
Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand, Jharkhand
Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh aur Bihar se alag kiye gaye.
- 2014
Telangana
2 June 2014 ko Andhra Pradesh se bana.
- 2019
Jammu and Kashmir ka reorganisation
State do Union Territories ban gaya, Jammu and Kashmir aur Ladakh. 2020 mein do chhoti Union Territories ke milne ke baad India mein 28 States aur 8 Union Territories hain.
Language kabhi akela test nahi thi. Nagaland aur Meghalaya north-east ke pahadi logon ki alag identities se bane. Uttarakhand aur Jharkhand Uttar Pradesh aur Bihar ke pahadi aur jungle wale regions se bane, jinke log door ki State capitals se ignored mehsoos karte the. Telangana ke log Andhra Pradesh ke apne padosiyon ki tarah Telugu bolte hain, lekin unhone regional aadhaar par apna State maanga.
Sattar saal baad, tootne ke shuruaati dar galat lagte hain. Ek Tamil ya Marathi bolne wala vyakti State government se deal kar sakta hai, court ja sakta hai aur exams apni language mein de sakta hai. Isse log India mein zyada apnapan mehsoos karte hain, kam nahi. Jahan officials aur citizens ek hi language bolte hain, wahan shaasan bhi aasaan ho gaya hai.
2.3.2 Language policy
Doosra test language tha. Socho ki Union government ka koi recruitment exam sirf Hindi mein likha ja sakta: Kerala, Odisha ya Assam ke zyadatar candidates shuru se hi nuksaan mein hote. India ka Constitution aisa nahi hone deta. Yeh koi national language tay hi nahi karta. Devanagari script mein Hindi Union ki official language hai. Lekin yeh aadhe se kam Indians ki mother tongue hai: 2011 Census mein 43.6 per cent.Tumhari textbook ek jagah ise ‘lagbhag 40 per cent’ aur doosri jagah ‘lagbhag 44 per cent’ round karti hai; Census ka figure 43.63 per cent hai. Isliye doosri languages ko mazboot protection milti hai.
Constitution ka Eighth Schedule 22 Scheduled Languages list karta hai, jinmein Hindi bhi hai. Union Public Service Commission ke civil services main examination mein candidates apne answers inmein se kisi bhi language mein ya English mein likh sakte hain. Har State apni official language ya languages bhi khud chunta hai, isliye Karnataka ka kisan State government se Kannada mein deal karta hai aur Punjab ka kisan Punjabi mein.
Sabse mushkil pal 1965 mein aaya. Constitution ne official kaam mein English ko sirf pandrah saal, 26 January 1965 tak, ki ijaazat di thi. Jaise hi deadline aayi, Madras State (ab Tamil Nadu) mein students aur parties ne protests shuru kiye jo hinsak ho gaye, aur doosre non-Hindi bolne wale States ne bhi unki chinta share ki. Union ne force ke bajaay samjhauta chuna: English Hindi ke saath chalti rahegi, aur yeh vaada 1967 mein Official Languages Act mein amendment karke law mein likha gaya. Kuch critics kehte hain ki asli faayda chhote English-educated elite ko hua.
Union aaj bhi official policy ke taur par Hindi ko badhava deti hai, lekin jin States ke log doosri languages bolte hain un par Hindi thop nahi sakti. India ke leaders ne sab par ek language thopne ke bajaay lachilapan dikhaya. Natije mein India us kadwe conflict se bach gaya jo 1956 mein Sri Lanka ke Sinhala ko apni akeli official language banane ke faisle ke baad hua.
India ki linguistic diversity
India ki languages ginna jitna lagta hai usse mushkil hai. 2011 Census mein logon ne apni mother tongues lagbhag 20,000 alag tareekon se likhi. Census experts ne pehle spellings aur duplicates ko milaya, jisse 1,369 alag mother tongues bachi. Phir unhone milti-julti tongues ko 121 languages mein group kiya; jaise Bhojpuri, Awadhi, Garhwali aur Haryanvi, sab Hindi ke under gine jaate hain. 121 mein se sirf 22 Eighth Schedule mein hain, aur baaki 99 non-Scheduled hain. Bahut kam countries is variety ke aas-paas bhi aate hain.
Fig. 2.6 ko upar se padho. Sabse lambi bar, 43.6 per cent wali Hindi, bhi aadhe wali line se pehle ruk jaati hai, aur doosri, Bengali, sirf 8 per cent tak pahunchti hai. Koi bhi language majority ki mother tongue nahi hai. Mother tongue ke roop mein English mushkil se dikhti hai, lagbhag 0.02 per cent Indians. Phir bhi lagbhag har das mein se ek Indian ne Census ko bataya ki woh ise doosri ya teesri language ki tarah jaanta hai.
2/2Agli nau languages mein se har ek 10 per cent se kam hai. Koi bhi language majority nahi hai.
Census 2011 se har language ko mother tongue ki tarah bolne wali India ki population ke hisse ka horizontal bar chart, jismein 50 per cent par ek dashed vertical line hai. Pehle step mein sirf Hindi ki bar dikhti hai, 43.63 per cent par, jo 50 per cent line se pehle ruk jaati hai. Doosre step mein uske neeche agli nau languages dikhti hain: Bengali 8.03, Marathi 6.86, Telugu 6.70, Tamil 5.70, Gujarati 4.58, Urdu 4.19, Kannada 3.61, Odia 3.10 aur Malayalam 2.88 per cent. Koi bhi bar line tak nahi pahunchti.
Answer dekho
Answer (A) Hindi Union ki official language hai, aur koi bhi language national language nahi hai
Answer dekho
Answer 43.6 %
Answer dekho
Answer Sahi
Answer dekho
- (A) Nagaland
- (C) Jharkhand
- (D) Telangana
2.3.3 Centre–State relations
Teesra badlaav New Delhi aur State capitals ke roz ke rishte mein aaya. Wahi constitutional rules udaarta se bhi laagu kiye ja sakte hain aur kanjoosi se bhi, aur yeh satta mein baithi parties ke vyavhaar se tay hota hai (Fig. 2.7).
1950 ke baad ke pehle dashakon mein ek hi party New Delhi aur zyadatar State capitals mein raaj karti thi. Chief Ministers apni party ke national leaders se ishaare lete the, isliye States apne constitutional rights par kam hi zor dete the. Virodhi parties ke chalaaye States ko zyada mushkil hoti thi. Unke khilaaf Centre ka pasandida hathiyaar Article 356 tha. Yeh Union ko kisi aise State par President's Rule lagane deta hai jiski government Constitution ke mutabik nahi chal sakti. Opposition parties ki chuni hui State governments ko is tarah baar-baar hataaya gaya, aur Justice R. S. Sarkaria ki leadership wale commission ne 1988 mein report di ki is article ka aksar galat use hua tha. Yeh federalism ki spirit ke khilaaf tha.
1990s ne yeh palat diya. Ek State mein jadein rakhne wali parties ek ke baad ek State mein mazboot hui. 1989 se 2014 tak kisi bhi Lok Sabha election ne kisi ek party ko apna majority nahi diya. Isliye is daur ki zyadatar Union governments coalition governments thi jo regional partners par nirbhar thi. Aise partners ki zaroorat wala Prime Minister States ko aasaani se nazarandaaz nahi kar sakta tha ya dhamka nahi sakta tha, aur State governments ka samman political life ka hissa ban gaya.
Do ya zyada political parties dwara milkar chalaayi jaane wali government, aam taur par ek agreed programme par, kyunki kisi ek party ke paas akele majority nahi hota.
Courts ne is trend ko aur mazboot kiya. 1994 ke S. R. Bommai case mein Supreme Court ne faisla diya ki State government ka majority Assembly ke floor par test hona chahiye. Usne yeh bhi faisla diya ki courts President's Rule ki proclamation ki jaanch kar sakte hain. Isse Centre ke liye apni marzi se State governments ko hataana bahut mushkil ho gaya. Tab se chuni hui State governments ko hataana kahin zyada kam ho gaya hai, aur States 1950s aur 1960s ke muqable Centre se kahin zyada confidence se mol-bhaav karte hain.
3/3S. R. Bommai judgment ne State governments ko manmaane dhang se hataana bahut mushkil bana diya.
Ek see-saw pivot par tika hai, left mein Centre likha box aur right mein States likha box. Pehle step mein see-saw Centre ki taraf neeche jhuka hai, caption ke saath early decades: Centre dominates. Doosre step mein States ki taraf regional parties likha ek dashed box jud jaata hai aur see-saw lagbhag barabar ho jaata hai, caption ke saath after 1990: coalitions. Teesre step mein pivot ke upar ek court building dikhti hai aur see-saw bilkul barabar ho jaata hai, caption ke saath 1994: court limits dismissals.
Answer dekho
Answer (C) Regional parties aur Centre mein coalition governments ka badhna
Answer dekho
Answer (A) Isne State governments ko manmaane dhang se hataana bahut mushkil bana diya
Answer dekho
Answer coalition
- States Reorganisation Act
- Andhra State bana
- Bommai judgment
- Telangana bana
- English khatam karne ki deadline
Answer dekho
- Andhra State bana
- States Reorganisation Act
- English khatam karne ki deadline
- Bommai judgment
- Telangana bana
2.4 India mein decentralisation
Itne bade country ke liye do tiers kaafi nahi hain. 2011 Census mein akele Uttar Pradesh mein lagbhag 20 crore log the, Brazil se zyada, aur Bihar ke 10.4 crore log Germany ki population se zyada the.Brazil ki 2010 census mein 19.1 crore log the aur Germany ki 2011 census mein 8.0 crore. Lucknow mein baitha Chief Minister yeh nahi jaan sakta ki saikdon kilometre door kisi district mein kis gaon ka kuan sookh gaya hai. Zyadatar States andar se bhi bahut diverse hain, isliye unke andar bhi power share karni padti hai. Yahi State ke neeche ek teesre tier, local government, ka tark hai. Ise teen manzila building ki ground floor samjho, woh floor jo logon ke asli rehne ki jagah ke sabse paas hai.
Central aur State governments se power aur paisa neeche local bodies tak le jaane ko decentralisation (विकेंद्रीकरण) kehte hain. Iske paksh mein teen tark hain. Jaankari: kisi ward ya gaon ke log sabse achhe se jaante hain ki kaun si naali mein baadh aati hai, kis school mein teacher nahi hai aur kaun si sadak baarish mein beh gayi. Behtar kharch: woh tay kar sakte hain ki inmein se kaun si zaroorat pehle hai aur paisa kaise use ho raha hai is par nazar rakh sakte hain. Participation: ghar ke paas liye gaye faisle aam citizens ko seedhe judne dete hain, aur yeh practice unhe behtar democrats banata hai. Milkar yeh ek purane democratic ideal ko poora karte hain: local self-government, yaani log apne local maamle khud chalayein.
Central aur State governments se power aur resources ko local governments, jaise panchayats aur municipalities, ko transfer karna.
ExampleEk gram panchayat ka yeh tay karna ki is saal gaon ki kaun si galiyan pakki ki jaayein.
Yeh idea purana hai. Constitution ka Article 40 State se gram panchayats organise karne ko kehta hai. 1959 mein Rajasthan ne pehla three-tier panchayati raj system shuru kiya; jald hi doosre States ne bhi yahi kiya, aur towns mein municipalities thi. Phir bhi teen dashakon tak yeh bodies State governments ki daya par rahi. Koi State unke elections saalon tak taal sakta tha ya apni marzi se unhe bhang kar sakta tha, aur unke paas apna paisa ya authority bahut kam thi. Kaagaz par power neeche aa gayi thi; asal mein nahi.
2.4.1 1992 ke amendments
Ek bada kadam 1992 mein aaya, jab Parliament ne do constitutional amendments paas kiye: rural local bodies ke liye 73rd aur urban ke liye 74th. Yeh 1993 mein laagu hue aur inhone local government ko democracy ka ek asli, constitution se protected teesra tier bana diya. Inse paanch bade badlaav aaye.
- Regular elections. Local bodies ke elections har paanch saal mein hone chahiye; agar koi body pehle bhang ho jaaye, to chhe mahine ke andar naya election hona chahiye.
- Reserved seats. Seats, aur in bodies ke heads ke posts, Scheduled Castes aur Scheduled Tribes ke liye unki population ke proportion mein reserved hain, aur States Other Backward Classes ke liye bhi seats reserve kar sakte hain.
- Kam se kam ek-tihaai women ke liye. Saari seats, aur heads ke posts, ka ek-tihaai se kam nahi, women ke liye reserved hai.
- State Election Commission. Har State mein ek independent State Election Commission panchayat aur municipal elections karwata hai.
- Powers aur paisa share karna. State governments ko local bodies ke saath kuch powers aur revenue share karna hota hai. Har paanch saal mein bana State Finance Commission sujhaata hai ki paisa kaise share ho. Practice mein States mein bahut farak hai ki woh kitna saunpte hain.
1992 se pehle aur baad ki local government
1992 se pehle
- Sirf State laws ke under exist karti thi
- Elections aksar saalon tak taale jaate the
- Women ke liye seats ka koi guaranteed hissa nahi
- Apni powers ya funds bahut kam
1992 ke baad
- Constitution se protected
- Har paanch saal mein elections, State Election Commission dwara
- Kam se kam ek-tihaai seats aur head posts women ke liye
- States ko kuch powers aur revenue share karna hi hoga
Answer dekho
Answer Galat
Answer dekho
Answer (B) State Election Commission
2.4.2 Panchayati raj: rural local government
Rural local government aam taur par panchayati raj (पंचायती राज) ke naam se jaani jaati hai. Iski sabse chhoti unit gram panchayat hai. Bade gaon ki apni gram panchayat hoti hai, jabki kuch States mein kuch chhote gaon milkar ek share karte hain. Gaon ka har ward ek member chunta hai, panch. Gaon ka ek head bhi hota hai, sarpanch (kuch States mein pradhan ya mukhiya kehte hain), jise zyadatar States mein voters seedhe chunte hain. Milkar yeh woh council banate hain jo poore gaon ke liye faisle leti hai (Fig. 2.8).
Panchayat bina roktok ke nahi chhodi jaati. Gaon ka har voter gram sabha (ग्राम सभा) ka member hai, jo gaon ki apni assembly hai. Jab yeh milti hai, to gaon wale sarpanch se sawaal kar sakte hain, panchayat ka saalana budget paas ya reject kar sakte hain aur uske kaam ko parakh sakte hain, kuch waise hi jaise shareholders company ke managers se sawaal karte hain. State laws tay karte hain ki ise kitni baar milna hai, aam taur par saal mein kam se kam do ya teen baar. Kai States gram sabha meetings 26 January, 15 August aur 2 October jaise dino par bulaate hain.
Gaon ke upar structure ka nazariya aur bada hota jaata hai. Panchayat samiti (kuch States mein block ya mandal panchayat kehte hain) gram panchayats ke ek group ko sambhaalti hai. Iske members chune jaate hain, aur kai States mein ilaake ke sarpanch bhi ismein baithte hain. Zilla parishad poore district ke liye planning karti hai. Iska zyadatar hissa chune hue members ka hota hai, lekin district ke Lok Sabha members aur MLAs ki bhi seats hoti hain, aur iska chuna hua chairperson iska political head hota hai.
4/4Zilla parishad district ko cover karti hai; local MPs aur MLAs bhi members hote hain.
Ek seedhidaar pyramid jiska heading panchayati raj hai. Pehle step mein sirf chauda base dikhta hai: gram sabha, all voters. Doosre step mein uske upar gram panchayat dikhti hai, jis par village likha hai, gram sabha se upar ek arrow jis par elects likha hai aur panchayat se neeche ek arrow jis par reports likha hai. Teesre step mein upar ek patla panchayat samiti box dikhta hai, jis par block likha hai. Chauthe step mein sabse patla box, zilla parishad, sabse upar dikhta hai, jis par district likha hai, aur ek note ki MPs aur MLAs bhi members hain.
2.4.3 Urban local government
Urban India ka apna version hai. Constitution size ke hisaab se teen tarah ki urban bodies deta hai. Nagar panchayat aisi jagah ke liye hai jo gaon se town ban rahi ho, municipality (municipal council) chhote town ke liye, aur municipal corporation Pune ya Kolkata jaise bade shehar ke liye. Har ek wards mein bata hota hai jinke voters councillors chunte hain. Municipality ka political head municipal chairperson hota hai; corporation mein yeh mayor hota hai, jise aksar shehar ka first citizen kaha jaata hai.
| Body | Members | Political head | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gaon | Gram sabha | Gaon ke saare voters | — |
| Gaon | Gram panchayat | Chune hue panch (ward members) aur sarpanch | Sarpanch |
| Block | Panchayat samiti | Chune hue members (aur kai States mein sarpanch) | Chairperson |
| District | Zilla parishad | Zyadatar chune hue members, saath mein local MPs aur MLAs | Chairperson |
| Town | Municipality | Chune hue ward councillors | Municipal chairperson |
| Shehar | Municipal corporation | Chune hue ward councillors | Mayor |
2.4.4 Yeh kitna achha chala hai?
Shayad kisi aur country mein kabhi ek saath itne log chune hue local office mein nahi rahe. Tumhari textbook poore India mein panchayats aur municipalities ke lagbhag 36 lakh chune hue members ginti hai, jo Uruguay jaise kisi country ki poori population se zyada hai.
Faayde asli hain. Local elections ab samay par hote hain, aur gaon wale badi sankhya mein vote dene aate hain. Reserved seats ne bahut badi sankhya mein women, Dalits aur Adivasis ko public life mein laaya hai, aksar pehli baar. 2006 mein Bihar panchayats mein women ke reservation ko 50 per cent tak badhaane wala pehla State bana, aur tab se kai States ne aisa hi kiya hai. Galiyon, paani aur schools ke faisle ab ghar ke paas bahas karke liye jaate hain, jisse democracy aur gehri hui hai.
Kamiyan bhi utni hi asli hain. Gram sabhas aksar kam milti hain, ya bahut kam log aate hain. Zyadatar States mein important powers ab bhi State government ke paas hain. Local bodies ke paas na itna fund hai na staff ki woh khud zyada kuch kar sakein, isliye woh upar se milne wali grants par nirbhar rehti hain. India ne lamba safar tay kiya hai, lekin sachcha local self-government abhi bhi kuch door hai.
Answer dekho
- (A) Reserved seat par chuni gayi ek woman sarpanch hand pump theek karwati hai aur school mein girls' toilet banwati hai
- (C) Gram sabha meeting mein gaon wale vote karte hain ki kaun si gali pehle pakki ho
Answer dekho
Answer (D) Gaon ke saare voters
Left mein koi item tap karo, phir right mein uska match.
Answer dekho
- Municipal corporation : Mayor
- Gram panchayat : Sarpanch
- Zilla parishad : Chairperson
- State Election Commission : Local elections karwata hai
Answer dekho
Answer one-third
Quick recall
Summary aur key points
- Federalism power ko ek central authority aur country ke hisson ki governments ke beech baant-ta hai, aur har ek ki powers constitution guarantee karta hai; Belgium 1993 mein federal bana jabki Sri Lanka unitary raha (Section 2.1).
- Unitary system ke ulat, federation mein centre States ko unke apne subjects par order nahi de sakta, aur dono levels logon ko jawab dete hain (Section 2.1.1).
- Key features: do ya zyada tiers, constitution dwara tay alag jurisdictions, ek-tarfa changes nahi, courts umpire ki tarah, alag revenue, aur unity aur diversity ke do goals (Section 2.1.2).
- Coming together federations (USA, Switzerland, Australia) mein barabar, mazboot States hote hain; holding together federations (India, Spain, Belgium) mein centre zyada mazboot hota hai aur units aksar asamaan hoti hain (Section 2.1.3).
- India ek ‘Union of States’ hai: Union, State aur Concurrent Lists law banane ki power baant-ti hain, Concurrent takraav mein Union law hi laagu hota hai, aur residuary subjects Parliament ke paas jaate hain (Section 2.2.1).
- Kuch States ke liye Articles 371 se 371J ke under special provisions hain, jabki Union Territories ko zyadatar Union chalati hai (Section 2.2.2).
- Powers ka batwara badalne ke liye dono Houses mein special majority aur kam se kam aadhi State legislatures ki approval chahiye; courts disputes settle karte hain, aur har level ke apne taxes hain (Section 2.2.3).
- Linguistic States, jinhe pehle unity ke liye khatra samjha gaya, ne India ko zyada ekjut aur shaasan mein aasaan banaya hai (Section 2.3.1).
- India ki koi national language nahi hai: Hindi Union ki official language hai, 22 Scheduled Languages protected hain, aur 1965 ke baad English official use mein bani rahi (Section 2.3.2).
- 1990 ke baad regional parties, coalition governments aur 1994 ke Bommai judgment ne Centre–State relations ko zyada balanced banaya (Section 2.3.3).
- Decentralisation power ko local governments tak le jaata hai; 1992 ke amendments ne elections ko regular banaya, SCs, STs aur women ke liye seats reserve ki, aur State Election Commissions banaye (Section 2.4.1).
- Panchayati raj ke teen tiers gram sabha ki nigrani mein hain, jabki towns mein municipalities aur shehron mein municipal corporations hain (Section 2.4.2).
- Local democracy ne participation badhaya hai, khaaskar women ki, lekin gram sabhas, powers aur funds ab bhi kamzor hain (Section 2.4.4).
Exercises: answers ke saath
India ke ek outline political map par Tripura, Telangana, Uttarakhand aur Kerala ko dhoondho aur label karo. Har ek ke liye ek padosi State ya country ka naam batao.
Solution dikhao
AnswerTripura: north-east; Telangana: Deccan plateau; Uttarakhand: Himalaya; Kerala: south-west coast.
- Tripura: north-east mein, lagbhag Bangladesh se ghira hua; iski seema Assam aur Mizoram se milti hai.
- Telangana: south-central India mein Deccan plateau par, Hyderabad iski capital hai; padosiyon mein Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, Andhra Pradesh aur Karnataka hain.
- Uttarakhand: north mein Himalaya mein; iski seema Himachal Pradesh aur Uttar Pradesh se milti hai, east mein Nepal aur north mein China (Tibet) hai.
- Kerala: south-west mein Arabian Sea coast ke saath ek patli patti; iski seema Karnataka aur Tamil Nadu se milti hai.
Duniya ke ek outline map par India ke alawa teen federal countries shade karo, har ek alag continent par, aur unke naam likho.
Solution dikhao
AnswerJaise Brazil (South America), Nigeria (Africa) aur Germany (Europe).
Alag continents par koi bhi teen, jaise: Brazil ya Argentina (South America); USA, Canada ya Mexico (North America); Germany, Switzerland ya Belgium (Europe); Nigeria ya Ethiopia (Africa); Australia (Oceania); Malaysia ya Pakistan (Asia).
Meera kehti hai, ‘India aur Belgium mein bilkul ek jaisa federalism hai.’ Ek point do jo uska saath deta hai aur ek point jo dikhata hai ki woh galat hai.
Solution dikhao
Uska saath deta hai: dono holding together federations hain. Dono mein ek pehle se maujood country ne apne regions ke saath power share karna chuna, aur central government kaafi mazboot rehti hai.
Dikhata hai ki woh galat hai: Belgium mein community governments ka ek alag tier hai, jise ek language group ke log chunte hain chahe woh country mein kahin bhi rehte hon, aur jo culture aur education jaise maamle sambhaalta hai. India ki units sirf territorial hain: States, Union Territories aur local bodies. (Ek aur farak: India ka Constitution panchayats aur municipalities ke teesre tier ko protect karta hai.)
Sri Lanka provinces mein bata hai aur India States mein, phir bhi Sri Lanka ko unitary aur India ko federal kaha jaata hai. In countries ko example lekar dono systems ka main farak samjhao.
Solution dikhao
Unitary system mein neeche ki units national government ke under hoti hain, jo unhe orders de sakti hai aur unki powers badal sakti hai. Sri Lanka mein practice mein lagbhag saari power national government ke paas hai, isliye uske provinces power ke independent centres nahi hain.
Federal system mein har level ki powers constitution se aati hain. India mein States ke State List mein apne subjects hain, jaise police; Union in maamlon par State ko order nahi de sakti ya akele arrangement nahi badal sakti, aur courts disputes settle karte hain.
Ravi ke dada 1980s mein panch the. Woh kehte hain, ‘Hamare zamane mein panchayat elections tab hote the jab State government ka mann karta tha.’ Do tareeke batao jinmein 1992 ke amendments ke baad ki local government unke bataye se alag hai.
Solution dikhao
- Ab elections har paanch saal mein hone chahiye, aur agar koi body pehle bhang ho jaaye to chhe mahine ke andar.
- Inhe ek independent State Election Commission karwata hai, State government nahi.
- Kam se kam ek-tihaai seats aur head posts women ke liye reserved hain, aur SCs aur STs ke liye seats reserved hain.
- States ko State Finance Commission ki salah se local bodies ke saath kuch powers aur revenue share karna hota hai.
Inmein se koi bhi do sawaal ka jawab hain.
Switzerland tab bana jab alag cantons aapas mein jude, isliye yeh together federation hai, aur iske cantons federal government ke muqable hain. Spain, ek bada country jisne apni power baanti, ek together federation hai, jismein government relatively zyada mazboot hai.
Answer dekho
Answer (1) coming, (2) strong, (3) holding, (4) central
Switzerland mazboot cantons wali coming together federation hai; Spain zyada mazboot central government wali holding together federation hai.India ki language policy par teen views yeh hain. Ek chuno, aur use ek tark aur ek example se support karo.
- Kavya: ‘Kyunki kisi par koi language thopi nahi gayi, kisi region ko nahi laga ki use India se bahar dhakela gaya.’
- Imran: ‘State borders ko language ke hisaab se kheenchne se language woh pehli cheez ban gayi jis par log jhagadte hain.’
- Tenzin: ‘Samjhaute ki asli jeet English ki hui, achhi naukriyon ki language.’
Solution dikhao
Kavya ke paksh mein: jab 1960s mein non-Hindi States ne protest kiya, to Centre ne English ko Hindi ke saath chalne diya aur Hindi nahi thopi. Tamil Nadu, jahan protests sabse tez the, mazbooti se India ka hissa raha. Sri Lanka se compare karo, jahan 1956 mein Sinhala ko akeli official language banane se Tamil bolne wale door ho gaye.
Imran ke paksh mein: language ke aadhaar par bane States mein lambe border disputes rahe hain, jaise Belagavi (Belgaum) ko lekar Maharashtra aur Karnataka ke beech, aur elections mein language aksar logon ko jodne ka mudda ban jaati hai.
Tenzin ke paksh mein: English, jo sirf lagbhag 0.02 per cent Indians ki mother tongue hai, aaj bhi higher courts, zyadatar higher education aur kai achhi tankhwah wali naukriyon ki language hai, isliye English mein padhe logon ko sabse zyada faayda hota hai.
Inmein se kya sirf federal government ke liye sach hai?
Answer dekho
Answer (C) National aur regional dono governments ke paas constitution dwara guaranteed powers hain.
Dono levels ke liye constitution se guaranteed powers hi federalism ki pehchaan hai. A powers ka horizontal separation hai, B unitary system ko describe karta hai, aur D kisi bhi democracy par laagu hota hai.Chhe subjects: atomic energy, prisons, trade unions, railways, fisheries aur electricity. Inhe teeno lists mein sort karo.
Union List mein kaun se hain?
Saare sahi options chunoAnswer dekho
Answer- (A) Atomic energy
- (D) Railways
Atomic energy aur railways ke liye ek national policy chahiye, isliye yeh Union subjects hain.State List mein kaun se hain?
Saare sahi options chunoAnswer dekho
Answer- (B) Prisons
- (E) Fisheries
Prisons aur fisheries State subjects hain.Concurrent List mein kaun se hain?
Saare sahi options chunoAnswer dekho
Answer- (C) Trade unions
- (F) Electricity
Trade unions aur electricity Concurrent hain: dono levels in par laws bana sakte hain.
Kaun sa joda sahi match nahi hai?
Answer dekho
Answer (B) Sirf State legislatures — Concurrent List
Concurrent subjects Parliament aur State legislatures dono ke hain, sirf States ke nahi. Baaki teen jode sahi hain.Har body ko uske description se match karo.
Left mein koi item tap karo, phir right mein uska match.
Answer dekho
Answer- Zilla parishad : Head ek chairperson
- Municipal corporation : Head ek mayor
- Gram sabha : Gaon ke saare voters
- State Election Commission : Local elections karwata hai
Zilla parishad ka head chairperson hota hai aur municipal corporation ka mayor; gram sabha gaon ka har voter hai; State Election Commission local elections karwata hai.Statements padho aur sahi option chuno.
- A. Federation mein constitution government ke har level ki powers saaf-saaf batata hai.
- B. Panchayats ko powers milne par India federation nahi raha.
- C. Koi country sirf isliye federal hai kyunki woh provinces mein bata hai.
- D. India mein agar Concurrent subject par Union law aur State law takraate hain, to Union law hi laagu hota hai.
Answer dekho
Answer (A) Sirf A aur D
A aur D sahi hain. B galat hai kyunki local government ne ek teesra tier joda aur federalism ko gehra kiya. C galat hai kyunki Sri Lanka mein provinces hain lekin woh unitary hai.
Practice questions answers ke saath (NCERT “Board exam practice”)
Powers ke batwaare ko lekar Union aur ek State ke beech ke disputes seedhe mein le jaaye ja sakte hain. (1 mark)
Answer dekho
Answer Supreme Court
Article 131 ke under Supreme Court governments ke beech ke disputes seedhe sunta hai.Assertion (A): Parliament computer software par laws bana sakti hai, bhale hi woh kisi list mein na ho. Reason (R): Constitution Union ko residuary subjects par law banane ki power deta hai. (1 mark)
Answer dekho
Answer (A) A aur R dono sahi hain, aur R, A ka sahi explanation hai.
Computer software residuary subject hai, aur residuary powers Parliament ke paas hain (Article 248), isliye R, A ko explain karta hai.Assertion (A): India mein saare States ke paas bilkul ek jaisi powers hain. Reason (R): India ek holding together federation hai. (1 mark)
Answer dekho
Answer (D) A galat hai, lekin R sahi hai.
R sahi hai. A galat hai: kai holding together federations ki tarah, kuch Indian States, jaise Nagaland aur Mizoram, ke liye special provisions hain.Koi teen tareeke samjhao jinse 73rd aur 74th Amendments ne India mein local government ko mazboot kiya. (3 marks)
Solution dikhao
- Har paanch saal mein regular elections zaroori ho gaye, isliye local bodies ko ab saalon tak chune hue members ke bina nahi rakha ja sakta.
- SCs aur STs ke liye seats aur head posts ka reservation, aur women ke liye kam se kam ek-tihaai, naye groups ko local power mein laaya.
- Ab ek independent State Election Commission local elections karwata hai, aur States ko kuch powers aur revenue share karna hota hai, jiske liye State Finance Commission tareeka sujhaata hai.
‘Linguistic States ke banne se Indian unity mazboot hui hai.’ Is statement ko teen points se justify karo. (3 marks)
Solution dikhao
- Log apne maamle apni language mein chala sakte the, isliye unhe samman mehsoos hua aur Union se naraaz hone ki wajah kam rahi.
- Administration aasaan ho gaya kyunki State mein officials aur citizens ek language share karte hain.
- Partition ke baad tootne ke dar sach nahi hue: log dono hona seekh gaye, jaise Tamil bhi aur Indian bhi, jabki Centre ke lachilepan ne conflict ki wajahein hata di.
India mein Union aur States ke beech power-sharing arrangement badalna mushkil kyun hai? Teen reasons do. (3 marks)
Solution dikhao
- Parliament ise akele nahi badal sakti: amendment ko dono Houses mein special majority chahiye.
- President tak pahunchne se pehle kam se kam aadhi State legislatures ko bhi ise approve karna hota hai.
- Courts Constitution ki raksha karte hain; Supreme Court ne maana hai ki federalism Constitution ka basic feature hai jise amendments khatam nahi kar sakte.
Linguistic States, language policy aur Centre–State relations ke reference mein samjhao ki sirf Constitution ne nahi, balki democratic politics ne India mein federalism ko kaise chalaya hai. (5 marks)
Solution dikhao
Linguistic States: Andhra State (1953) aur 1956 ke reorganisation se aage, States ko is tarah dobara kheencha gaya ki ek language bolne wale saath rahein; doosre, jaise Nagaland aur Jharkhand, ne cultural ya regional identities ko maanyata di. Shuru mein ispar dar tha, lekin isne India ko zyada ekjut aur shaasan mein aasaan banaya.
Language policy: koi national language thopi nahi gayi. Hindi official language bani, 22 languages Scheduled hain, aur non-Hindi States ke protest ke baad 1965 ke baad bhi English chalti rahi. Is lachilepan ne Sri Lanka jaise conflict se bachaaya.
Centre–State relations: shuruaati dashakon mein ek party haavi thi aur virodhi State governments ke khilaaf Article 356 ka galat use hua. 1990 ke baad regional parties aur coalition governments ne Centre ko States ka samman karne par majboor kiya, aur 1994 ke Bommai judgment ne manmaane dhang se hataane par rok lagayi.
Conclusion: federalism ki spirit democratic politics se badhi, sirf constitutional text se nahi.
‘Coming together’ aur ‘holding together’ federations mein farak batao, aur samjhao ki India holding together federation kyun hai. (5 marks)
Solution dikhao
Coming together: independent States apni marzi se milkar ek bada union banate hain, apni identity rakhte hue suraksha paate hain. Member States ke paas aam taur par barabar powers hoti hain aur woh federal government ke muqable mazboot rehte hain. Examples: USA, Switzerland, Australia.
Holding together: ek bada maujooda country apne hisson ke saath power share karne ka faisla karta hai. Central government zyada mazboot hoti hai, aur units ke paas asamaan powers ho sakti hain. Examples: India, Spain, Belgium.
India: India independent States ke agreement sign karne se nahi bana; Constitution ne federation banayi aur India ko ek atoot ‘Union of States’ kehta hai. Union List mein sabse important subjects hain, Concurrent takraav mein Union law hi laagu hota hai, residuary powers Parliament ke paas jaati hain, aur kuch States, jaise Nagaland, ko special provisions milte hain, isliye units asamaan hain.
Case padho aur sawaalon ke jawab do. (4 marks)
Sundarpur gaon mein is term sarpanch ka post ek woman ke liye reserved hai, aur Lalita Devi, jo pehle anganwadi helper thi, election jeet-ti hain. Saal ki pehli gram sabha meeting mein gaon ke 900 voters mein se lagbhag 60 aate hain. Woh gaon ke talaab ki marammat aur primary school mein ramp banane ka plan approve karte hain. Phir panchayat State government se funds ka intezaar karti hai, jo chhe mahine der se aate hain.
Kis constitutional provision ne Lalita Devi ke post ko reserved banaya?
Answer dekho
Answer (A) Women ke liye kam se kam ek-tihaai seats aur head posts ka reservation
73rd Amendment women ke liye kam se kam ek-tihaai seats aur head posts, sarpanch posts samet, reserve karta hai.Kitne percentage voters gram sabha meeting mein aaye, aur yeh local democracy ki kaun si problem dikhata hai?
Solution dikhao
AnswerLagbhag 6.7 per cent; gram sabhas mein aksar bahut kam log aate hain.
60 ÷ 900 × 100 ≈ 6.7 per cent. Itne kam logon ke hone par ek chhota group poore gaon ke liye faisla karta hai, aur gram sabha panchayat ki theek se nigrani nahi kar paati.
Funds mein der decentralisation ki kaun si kamzori dikhati hai? Ek hal sujhao.
Solution dikhao
Local bodies paise ke liye State governments par nirbhar hain aur unke paas apne resources nahi hain. Hal: State Finance Commission ki salah ke mutabik samay par funds jaari karna, funds seedhe panchayats ko transfer karna, ya panchayats ko apna zyada revenue jutaane dena, jaise local taxes aur fees.
Map skill: India ke ek outline political map par neeche diye gaye ko dhoondho aur label karo. (3 marks)
Woh State jo Andhra State se bana, jo ek language ke liye bana pehla State tha (1953).
Solution dikhao
AnswerAndhra Pradesh.
Andhra State (1953) 1956 mein Andhra Pradesh bana; yeh Bay of Bengal ke saath east coast par hai.
1960 mein Bombay State ke batwaare se bane do States.
Solution dikhao
AnswerMaharashtra aur Gujarat.
Maharashtra aur Gujarat, dono Arabian Sea ke saath west coast par, Gujarat north mein.
India ka sabse naya State, 2014 mein bana.
Solution dikhao
AnswerTelangana.
Telangana, Deccan plateau par, 2 June 2014 ko Andhra Pradesh se bana.
Apna NCERT exercise question dhoondo
Hamare practice questions ncert.ai ke liye likhe gaye hain aur NCERT exercises ko follow karte hain. Apni textbook ke question se match karne wala question dhoondo; uska answer uske saath hai.
| Tumhari NCERT textbook mein | Yahan practice question |
|---|---|
| NCERT Exercises Q1 | Practice Q1 |
| NCERT Exercises Q2 | Practice Q2 |
| NCERT Exercises Q3 | Practice Q3 |
| NCERT Exercises Q4 | Practice Q4 |
| NCERT Exercises Q5 | Practice Q5 |
| NCERT Exercises Q6 | Practice Q6 |
| NCERT Exercises Q7 | Practice Q7 |
| NCERT Exercises Q8 | Practice Q8 |
| NCERT Exercises Q9 | Practice Q9 |
| NCERT Exercises Q10 | Practice Q10 |
| NCERT Exercises Q11 | Practice Q11 |
| NCERT Exercises Q12 | Practice Q12 |
Quick check: MCQs
- 2.1.3 Federation tak pahunchne ke do raaste4 questions
- 2.2.1 Teen lists4 questions
- Faisla kaun karta hai?4 questions
- India ki linguistic diversity4 questions
- 2.3.3 Centre–State relations4 questions
- 2.4.1 1992 ke amendments2 questions
- 2.4.4 Yeh kitna achha chala hai?4 questions
Key terms (English + Hindi)
- coalition governmentगठबंधन सरकारgathbandhan sarkar
- Do ya zyada parties dwara milkar chalaayi jaane wali government, aam taur par ek agreed programme par.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- coming together federation
- Aisi federation jo independent States ke milkar ek bada country banane se bani ho, jaise USA.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- Concurrent Listसमवर्ती सूचीsamvarti soochi
- Woh subjects jin par Parliament aur State legislatures dono laws bana sakti hain, jaise education; takraav mein Union law hi laagu hota hai.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- decentralisationविकेंद्रीकरणvikendrikaran
- Central aur State governments se power aur resources ko local governments tak le jaana.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- federalismसंघवादsanghvaad
- Aisa system jismein power ek national government aur regional governments ke beech share hoti hai, aur har ek apni powers constitution ke under rakhti hai.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- gram sabhaग्राम सभाgram sabha
- Gaon ke saare voters ki assembly; yeh gram panchayat ki nigrani karti hai.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- holding together federation
- Aisi federation jo ek bade country ke apne regions ke saath power share karne se bani ho, jaise India.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- jurisdictionक्षेत्राधिकारkshetradhikar
- Kisi government ya court ki legal authority ka daayra: woh territory jo uske under aati hai ya woh subjects jinse woh deal karti hai.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- panchayati rajपंचायती राजpanchayati raj
- Gaon, block aur district level par chuni hui panchayats ke zariye rural local government ka system.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- residuary subjectsअवशिष्ट विषयavashisht vishay
- Woh subjects jo teeno lists mein se kisi mein nahi; India mein un par Parliament laws banati hai.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- Scheduled Languagesअनुसूचित भाषाएँanusoochit bhashayen
- Constitution ke Eighth Schedule mein list ki gayi 22 languages.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- State Listराज्य सूचीrajya soochi
- Woh subjects jin par sirf State legislatures laws bana sakti hain, jaise police aur agriculture.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- Union Listसंघ सूचीsangh soochi
- Woh subjects jin par sirf Parliament laws bana sakti hai, jaise defence, banking aur currency.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- Union Territoryकेंद्रशासित प्रदेशkendrashasit pradesh
- Aisa area jise zyadatar Union government chalati hai, State ki poori powers ke bina.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →
- unitary systemएकात्मक व्यवस्थाekatmak vyavastha
- Aisa system jismein government ka ek level hota hai, ya neeche ke levels sirf woh laagu karte hain jo national government tay karti hai.Chapter mein pehli baar yahan aaya →